[digg=http://digg.com/arts_culture/If_a_Book_Is_Good_Does_It_Matter_How_It_Was_Published]With the hullabaloo about the SterlingHouse Publishers booth at BEA last week, I started thinking about how important the publishing house is to the success of a book.
Publishers provide important services (editing, design, production) and the access to online and bricks-and-mortar stores that the average self-published book simply won’t get.
And the dangers of self-publishing, with its high price tags and the virtual impossibility of getting those books into stores where consumers could actually buy them, are well documented. (Writers Beware is one source of information, but there are certainly others. A quick web search will net a wealth of information.)
But, if a book is good, does it really matter whether it came from a vanity publisher or a traditional publisher? If all other variables were controlled, would a good book that came from a publisher notorious in the industry for releasing unedited crap stand a chance? Would reviewers throw away their review copies unopened, unwilling to waste their and their readers’ time on a book that is obviously junk? Would readers take a chance on a new author from a publisher that had a bad reputation? Or from a self-published author who had done all of the due diligence of a traditional publisher?
My inclination is that it would still matter. Even if the author was the next great national treasure, he or she would always be tainted by the reputation of the shoddy publisher or the vanity press. The distribution variables simply can’t be controlled. A traditional publisher has a much greater ability to distribute books than a single author has. And, really, what good is a book if no one reads it?
Related Posts - Writing Roundup, October 9 Here is a handy table of contents that will help you quickly reach the topic of your choice. Let me know if you like it this way. The Business of Writing Craft Fiction Freelancing Platform Special Section: The FTC Rules The Business of Writing Letting the Market Speak The Waxman......
- Writing Roundup, December 11 The Business of Writing Craft Fiction Freelancing Platform The Business of Writing Should Publishers Delay E-book Releases? This was big story this week, as publishers reported that they would try to save paper publishing by delaying important e-book releases. Agent Nathan Bransford explains the flaws in the logic and......
- Writing Roundup, August 28 Lots of good stuff out there as we look toward the fall. The Business of Writing How a Book Gets Published Agent Nathan Bransford gives a great, easy-to-follow description of how a book goes from finished clean copy on the author's desk to a shiny new book on the shelves.......
- Writing Roundup, October 23 The Business of Writing Craft Fiction Freelancing Platform The Business of Writing Before You Sign That Publishing Contract Diane Craver guests at Writers Weekly to remind us to take time to read our publisher contracts, assess the points, and decide whether the contract is really right before we sign.......
- Writing Roundup, July 24 The Business of Writing Ain't That a Shame Author Justine Larbalestier shares her thoughts on the cover for her book Liar. The protagonist is African American, but the girl shown on the cover is White. Larbalastier campaigned strongly for a different cover, but she did not win that battle. What......
Related Websites - Free Book Marketing Advice – Make Your Book A Business - Webinar with Brian Jud Download a pre-release production schedule where you put in your proposed release date and it provides a backwards calendar, showing the promotional and marketing actions...
-
Review: A Bride in the Bargain by Deeanne Gist I didn’t know I was thirsting for this type of novel until I glutted myself on it. The story itself is an inspirational set in... - Review of Alan Corey's A Million Bucks by 30 I received a complimentary copy -- autographed by the author, no less! -- of A Million Bucks by 30. This book will be available in...
- Book Review: The Encyclopedia of the Violin The Encyclopedia of the Violin was first published in 1925 as a comprehensive reference of the history and evolution of the violin. It is still...
- The Leader Who Had No Title - Book Giveaway I'd like to introduce a new book by Robin Sharma - The Leader Who Had No Title: A Modern Fable on Real Success in Business...
I think it will always matter. I know lots of self-published authors are great writers with wonderful books, but to the rest of the industry they still look like rebels.
If your book was rejected 100 times, that doesn’t mean it was *bad*. It does, however, mean the book didn’t fit the current market for some reason. It doesn’t matter that the writing is brilliant and flawless–it just won’t sell in the traditional marketplace.
So agents and editors see that you’re self-published. Sure, some self-published authors get picked up by the daring and progressive agent. However, many/most don’t.
Many will see you as delusional for thinking your book was so great it just had to be published despite not succeeding in the traditional arena; others will see you as a brilliant niche-market author whose writing is wonderful but still not suited to the current market. Unfortunately, usually neither spells success.
It’s a tough place to be, especially for the self-published authors whose work really is great.
It WILL ALWAYS matter. I know of one self published writer. She published her book to go along with the NC fourth grade curriculum. It is a historical novel, did very well. She had a lot of money and was able to advertise her book. She told me that traditional publishers look down on her for self publishing. I want to traditionally publish and besides that, Jen, I don’t have that kind of money. Sad but true!
Nice post though. I enjoyed reading it.
I think it will matter, as no matter how self-publishing will be portrayed, there is the “junk” factor… You never know what’s inside the cover until you read it… which means having bought a non-returnable book.
Jen, Robyn, and Rebecca, We’re definitely on the same page. I think the vanity publishers are predatory. They use the fears and frustration of would-be authors to make money.
If my current WIP isn’t right for the market, I will keep it on ice and work on the next WIP. There’s always room for my descendants to posthumously release my unpublished early novels.
To me it doesn’t matter who published a book. I know of no reader to whom it does (although I’m sure they exist.) I’ve bought several self-published books.
Also, I’ve self published a novel (not through one of the predatory, expensive vanity presses.) In fact, to publish it cost me a grand total of $5.31 (or something like that) that paid for the printing of a proof copy.
Self publishing has allowed me to reach a large number of readers that would never know who I am if I hadn’t self-published. I’m (hopefully) building a following that will help me show that I deserve to be published my a big house. If I never do get “picked up”, I’ll at least have the experience (& feedback) of sharing my work with as many folks as possible.
I self published because I felt like doing so would help me meet my goals as an author. If are interested in all my reasons, there’s a post on my blog thatlays it out. http://www.storyhack.com/2009/01/02/why-did-i-self-publish/
I did approach one traditional publisher. That story is embedded in the post I mentioned.
What do you mean by reviewed? Several bloggers have reviewed it, many visitors to my site have reviewed it, and there are a few Amazon reviews as well. Big name or newspaper reviews? Not yet.
To date, I have only sold a couple hundred copies of my book. However, traffic on my site has climbed from about 1,300 a month to 2,300 a month in the six months it’s been out. Having people see the book I’m sure has helped out with that.
Also, I haven’t really done all that much to market my book. This summer should change that a little, as I’ve got some things going on – I’ll be getting a review on one of podcast that specializes in the genre of my book, I’ve got an audio trailer that’s appearing on another popular podcast later this summer, and I was interviewed for yet another fairly popular podcast, and that should be out in a week or two. Oh, and I have an ad page for my book that will be showing up in several other self published books in my genre. None of this by the way cost me anything – other than occasionally a copy of my book.
I have an acquaintance in the same genre that’s been a little more on the ball with the marketing. In the 10 months her book has been out, she’s sold over 1,200 copies.
I’m not looking to get rich, or even necessarily become a full time author. Self-Publishing just seemed to be a good fit for me.
Thanks again, Bryce. This is all very interesting food for thought.
I think for my goals, traditional publishing is the best bet. But I have enjoyed reading a but more about your experiences.
The Mad Editor’s Round-Up #8 | Diary of a Mad Editor // Jun 8, 2009 at 10:44 am
[...] Roland presents If a Book Is Good, Does It Matter How It Was Published? posted at Jen’s Writing Journey, saying, “Is POD a viable form of publishing? How can [...]
The Self Published Carnival #3 – Story Hack // Jul 2, 2009 at 4:54 pm
[...] Jennifer Ferroland from Jen’s Writing Journey sought answers this month to the age old question – If a Book Is Good, Does It Matter How It Was Published? [...]
Bryce,
Thanks for sharing your experiences with self-publishing. What led you to self-publishing? Have you also approached traditional publishers with your work? Have you had your work reviewed? How are you selling?
Jennifer